Pages

Thursday, April 15, 2021

Law & Order SVU “Our Words Will Not Be Heard” Recap, Review, Discussion Topic



There were a lot of things packed into Law & Order SVU “Our Words Will Not Be Heard”.   There were so  many things going on that I had a hard time holding on and following some of it.   The story moved with such a fast pace – almost too fast – that I found myself getting confused as to who was who in relation to the SVU case.   I enjoyed having some personal news about the main characters for a change, however.   The victims' story, though, would have made an excellent stand-alone "SVU/hate crime" episode.

Before the episode opens, we see a recap of the SVU’s involvement in the Jayvon Brown case, previously covered in the episode “Guardians and Gladiators.” (More on this later.)    The follow up to the Jayvon issue would also have made a great stand alone episode.  

Prior to the SVU getting involved in the episode's special victims case,  we hear that Kat is being promoted to detective. Fin spills the beans to Kat to alert her to the “surprise” and needless to say, Kat opens her mouth right away to Benson and proves that Fin can’t keep a secret.  It also shows that Kat is still too impulsive.   We also see Fin’s fiancée Phoebe and the gorgeous ring Fin gave to her. Benson comments she’s never seen Fin happier.  We are ALL happy for him. I worry, however, that in typical television fashion this will lead to tragedy somewhere down the road because no one is ever allowed to be happy on TV crime shows.  I was also expecting a bit more screen time for Jennifer Esposito in this episode, and was disappointed.

Benson was in the hot seat with IAB regarding the Jayvon Brown case.   But IAB tells her she will be cleared of all wrongdoing;  One PP doesn’t want to show weakness. Later, Benson arrives for her deposition and despite that she should know better than to talk to Jayvon alone with no attorneys present, Benson does so anyway. She tells him what the NYPD needs to do to fix the culture.  Yes, Benson has ALL the answers here. Deputy Chief Garland later speaks with Benson about the demands Jayvon has made and says to her that it was almost as if  Jayvon’s people had someone on the inside telling them what to ask for.  My guess is he knows exactly where the suggestions came from.  By the way, Garland tells Benson that there is a perception that Stabler is going rogue at Organized Crime (no surprise here),  and she says she doesn’t know anything about that.  Garland reminds her they are all under scrutiny and Benson is well aware.  He reminds her to keep her distance – he can’t afford to lose her. 

A question - I don’t understand all the nuances of warrants but when Benson was trying to access a resident’s basement,  I didn’t understand why she said a missing woman would mean a warrant is not needed. Can anyone shine some light on this?  Was Benson simply lying in order to gain access? 

Now, the case: Two girls, Sara and Alicia - who is in a wheelchair -  are kidnapped, thinking that the people who offered them a ride have kind intentions.  They were likely lulled into a feeling of security by the presence of a young boy with the man and woman who convinced them to accept the ride.   Sadly, the young boy was just part of the couple’s ruse. 

The sister of one of the girls, Nicole, a lawyer, raises the flag about Sara’s disappearance.  Nicole and Carisi enter the SVU squad room to speak to Benson about it, and before they enter Benson’s office, Nicole wonders if Carisi has told Benson about them. Carisi explained he said they were “just friends”.  Clearly this relationship is what Carisi wanted to tell Rollins about in the previous episode but news of her father’s illness cut that short. By the way, Rollins was not involved in the case, and while it was never stated in this episode, we assume that, based on what happened in the previous episode, that she is with her sick father. 

Alicia is released by the kidnappers.  In the hospital, Alicia explains the girls were videotaped being forced to perform sex acts on each other and the video would be posted on the internet.  They  later see the video on the web site “Crew 23/2”  - this is white hate group out of New Jersey – and Sara’s fate is up for auction. with a time limit for bids. With the clock ticking – literally – the SVU works the case.

The SVU connects with someone working on a construction site who is working undercover.  With clues from  him, they are able to track down the woman involved – Molly Anderson. In SVU interrogation, they press Molly to give them the location where Sara is being held.   She resists doing so. Making matters worse, Nicole has gone on television to make an appeal, throwing a wrench into the mix.  Eventually Molly explains that her brother knows where they are – he is the other man in the video besides her husband  Ricky – and says she can text him an SOS.  She sends the message and we can see him on the live feed seeing the message, but soon afterward we hear a gunshot.   

TARU is able to triangulate the cell phone and narrow it to a 5 block radius in Chelsea. They find that Ricky  has 5 clients in that neighborhood.  With SVU and other officers – including Garland – they swarm the area and ask the residents to see their basements. If the person refuses, they are instructed to get backup.  One man asks to see their warrant and  Benson says they don’t need one as they are tracking a missing woman.   They hear from other officers that someone heard the gun shot and they converge on one location and find Molly's brother there, injured.  When he won’t tell them the location, Benson cancels the bus/EMS, telling him he will bleed out.  He must have caved in to Benson, as they later rescue Sara and catch up with Molly’s creepy husband Ricky, who is live streaming the arrest.  

Nicole is reunited with Sara, and Nicole worries if SVU will look out for other victims in the future.  Benson says they will. 

The episode ends with Garland’s warnings to Benson (mentioned above).  Benson’s troubles may not be over. 



20 comments:

  1. This blog post has been updated with my recap/review! Thanks for your patience.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Exigent circumstance allows the police not to have a warrant as in this instance.

    ReplyDelete
  3. They should just forget all the Jayvon stuff. Unless it's about another shot at the rapist who framed him, let it go. The Christian Cooper incident is pretty dated at this point, with much more egregious cases are playing out nowadays.

    This one was kind of a weaker Weeping Willow, as there's really no ambiguity as to whether or not the victim is in on it. Also, was this episode originally meant to be the backdoor pilot for the Hate Crimes spinoff? It seemed like they were about to introduce those detectives and then didn't. I'd still like to see that show happen (maybe on Peacock?).

    ReplyDelete
  4. Sorry but this episode was a load of crap. Benson would let someone bleed to death for not cooperating? And Garland thinks that just fine. Either she faked calling off the bus or as you said he caved. But I guess it’s okay to let a white person die. They are going so far with this virtue signaling SJW crap I’d stop watching except I want to see how things play out with her and Stabler. I guess she doesn't heed Garland’s advice as she’s in OC next week. I’m curious after the way he blew her off how she gets invited to a family gathering. Anyway, this was a crappy episode. The ones that aren’t are few and far between.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Calling off the bus is definitely not ok. Not the first time we see people bend rules to save victims or help friends. What bothers me the most is the victims sister going on tv and saying the NYPD is not doing all they can, when Olivia broke the rules and put her career on the line to save her sister. So much for not caring

      Delete
  5. Unsure if my issues with the episode line up with the uh. SJW tip, but I will say it felt very outlandish and far fetched. I was glad she didn't die but the show feels like it's feeling through news headlines like never before.

    I miss having a central cast. It's like random appearances in proximity to Olivia.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I agree. It feels less like Special Victims and more like the Olivia Benson show.

      Delete
  6. @Esaukl - thanks. I actually forgot about the ticking clock and the time limit on the bidding. Maybe it was the way Benson framed it - I would think a simple issue of a missing person would not allow them access to any location without a warrant. If she would have said that the missing woman was in danger of being harmed or killed, I probably wouldn't have had the issue with her actions.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Sorry @Esaul about that spelling. I think my fingers went a bit crazy!


    ReplyDelete
  8. They took two stories (the kidnap and Benson/IAB/Jayvon) and put them in a blender. Then they added something about Carisi's relationship, Kat's promotion, and Phoebe, and blended all of it together. Did it blend well? No. The kidnapping was a story of itself, and Benson getting in trouble with IAB and the legal issues with Jayvon another episode. The short season probably made them throw this all together. It was a mess but still watchable.

    As far as the warrant - I just saw your comment Chris and I agree with you. I don't think a missing person is grounds to get into anyone's home. Benson should have said, "we are in search of a missing woman who's life is in imminent danger. We can enter without a warrant."

    How convenient Carisi's new friend has a case that perfectly fits SVU! She does something stupid by going on TV. The relationship is doomed!

    Poor Kat. Her promotion gets barely minutes of screen time. Jennifer Esposito got less. A shame.

    ReplyDelete
  9. I know some didn't like the way they touched on racism and white supremacy which they have the right to feel but at the same time, it seems it's a lose lose. If they tackle these subjects, people are mad. If they don't, people are still mad. 1. This is nothing new, they've been doing this so why some are NOW bothered is beyond me. 2. I personally thought they touched on it well but that's just me. I was more bothered (besides the disturbing crime) by how Elliot is being made out as a jerk and the same hothead and rule breaker from the old days, it screams Stabler haters by the writers. 1. The old Olivia Benson would know and understand that Elliot meant "back off" as in "this is too dangerous and I'm not putting your life at risk so I'm telling you to stay away from this for your own safety" not "leave me alone" like Olivia took it to mean. Then at the end, the whole Elliot "going rogue" when that's been the opposite in OC (mostly). I know some "Rollisi" shippers are upset over Carisi with Nicole but I'm here for their relationship, I honestly don't want him with Amanda. Also, I'm glad that Kat's a detective now.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. You make some interesting points about Elliot. The writers on SVU were not there during the Stabler years. Also the writers for OC are totally new. So I don’t the writers in either show really understand the Stabler Benson dynamic. I felt that in the first episode of OC in that scene at the park. Olivia was so cold to him. It just felt off. But there’s also a ten year gap and a lot hurt in Olivia’s part. I don’t know that she didn’t understand what he meant by back off I think she probably wasn’t going to go into detail with Fin. Elliot told her she meant the world him then he said back off. I also was perplexed by the going rogue comment. Aside from Elliot finding Sinatra and taking his phone what has he done? Only Bell knows that and he was attacked by someone.

      Delete
    2. Exactly and what you said about Olivia probably not about to go into detail with Fin makes more sense now.

      Delete
  10. Interesting how you wrote, “ I was also expecting a bit more screen time for Jennifer Esposito in this episode, and was disappointed.” And yet I thought you don’t like family interwoven with the case? You hate the Stabler family, you’re not crazy about Noah, and, weirdly, you do like Fin’s fiancé

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. @Jeanette - I don’t care for the kids. Stabler’s kids have always annoyed me because at times they have dominated a story. I don’t care for Noah for similar reasons. I don’t mind the personal lives of the characters until they become too much of a focus on the episode. When I saw Jennifer Esposito on the guest stars list, I just expected more than a few seconds on the screen. And Fin has received so little personal stores over the years he’s been on, he deserves more. I take every episode as they come. Some can fit a heavy family focus and others not,

      Delete
  11. This is a little off-topic, but I'm still thinking about the reunion of Stabler and Benson in the earlier episode. Something seems wrong about the timing of the car bombing. If Kathy Stabler had been concerned about them being late for Olivia's award ceremony, wouldn't that mean that it was close to the start of that event? Then it would be possible that Liv was on her way there too, so couldn't she have come across the bombing site by coincidence, not by being alerted to go there? And wouldn't she have been wearing her dress uniform, en route to the ceremony?

    ReplyDelete
  12. Episode was okay but Olivia acted unethically leaking information to Jayvon. Her total loyalty should be to 1PP.

    ReplyDelete
  13. When I saw the flashbacks to that past episode I was like oh no not this again, not when I've just started trusting you lol but it turned out to be an excellent episode and a good cleaning up of the messaging in the original one. Jayvon seemed soo different from the guy in the initial ep but I liked that they improved him and he wasn't just some belligerent Black guy. I have often complained about how Olivia comes across but I did not find her obnoxious at all in this ep. Rather I think it made it believable again that she could be an ally for disenfranchised ppl. I thought her convo w J was good tv and it is nice to imagine a world where this kind of dialogue could take place. Benson's pt that J's team "doesn't want money they want change" made me think of a seminar I went to years ago where they talked about the sexual abuse cases in Catholic Church. Those survivors were often vilified as just being after money. The presenter showed how many of them really are working for the Church to change how it handles this issue, also that for many $$ is the only way to have some type of acknowledgement that something happened. 

    I was very surprised to see Carisi's new love interest was Black. Just never imagined him dating someone who looked like that. I'm sure the decision to cast her is going to lead to a lot of "misogynoir" in some viewers. I'm already seeing it on other platforms but regardless of what she looks like I just like that we're exploring other stories for Carisi and Amanda. The Rollisi stuff was endearing seasons ago but the storyline is tired now

    I recently saw a news video of Black woman afraid to call cops on a White man who had pulled a gun on her. She and her husband had been renting business space from him. He asked to meet with her and started saying racist things that were making her uncomfortable. She secretly texted her husband to come. He showed up just as the owner had pulled a gun on the woman. Husband was able to restrain him and kept calling out to the wife to call the police but she was afraid that to do so would end with her Black husband being killed. She did call in the end but ran outside and wouldn't let the cops in till she had repeated several times it was the White guy who was the assailant. People can talk about SJW and virtue signalling but none of that changes the complicated relationship Black ppl have with the police esp these days and how that affects the ability to seek help from the police. Not every Black person is a criminal but many are very afraid of being treated like one. They're getting hate for it but it's impressive to see SVU take it on and in a more thoughtful way than I've seen them do it before (1/2)

    ReplyDelete
  14. This brings me to Nicole. She clearly doesn't feel the police care enough about Black ppl and she is not alone in that view. When you lack trust you're gonna be inclined to do the exact opposite of what the person is telling you to do. When you've been silenced so long and told your story doesn't matter you're going to be hypervigilant about being shushed. Those two things can have you working against your own interest at times. Her actions could have costed her sister's life. It frustrated me to see her on tv and as I looked at her I could see the distrust, I could see the "nobody's going to shush me" And understanding her is not condoning like you can understand why someone turned to drugs and not condone it. She was dead wrong to go on tv but I really did get what led her there

    In the past, Black episodes of SVU were like a Star Trek episode where they go to some planet and for the entire episode you'll see *a lot* of a species that you will unlikely see again for the rest of the season (bar that one crew member originally from that planet). Now SVU is starting to feel like it's based in NY with a more regular appearance of Blacks and other minorities. We're part of the society now and not on our own planet with annual visits and I'm here for it. 

    I liked the lighter moments like Fin spilling the beans and Carisi and Nicole thinking they're being so covert about their rel and Liv & Fin figure it out in 0.2 secs. Overall I think was another great ep this season. Lots of eps that I find myself wanting to rewatch (2/2)

    ReplyDelete
  15. The kid who lures the girls into the van should be in juvie until he's 18 AT LEAST. He was part of the kidnapping and torture. His mother should be in prison as well because she only cooperated when threatened with the death penalty. No free pass for you, evil b**ch.
    Hopefully Rick and Steve were sent to ADX Florence and locked in their cells 23 hours a day with the worst of the worst. Or better yet, throw them to a black prison gang and let them become someone's boyfriend.

    ReplyDelete